PDA

View Full Version : Maintenance Weekly 7th August - Journalling


Mitra
08-07-2006, 06:30 AM
Make the commitment that if it goes into your mouth, it goes into your journal. Studies have shown that people who commit to keeping an honest and accurate diary of nutrition and exercise are as much as four times more successful than people who will not.

This week's tip from the Staying Power journal section.

I think I used this one last year, too - but that was on the other board, and cmcole's new personal journal made me think it might be worthwhile to revisit the idea.

After my first couple of weeks on intervention, I'd pretty much learned what I could have lots of, only a bit of, or none at all of, and didn't bother journalling. Then I reached goal, relaxed a bit, and regained about half a stone :rolleyes: (that's seven pounds). That was when I started journalling. I did it for a few months, lost those pounds, and stabilised. A few months later just a couple of pounds had crept on, and this time I did six months of recording everything - calories, carbs, protein, fat.

I stopped towards the end of last year and so far have maintained my weight without recording it, but my experience does agree with the Eadeses' recommendation to journal for at least a year. It really helped me to see what effect variations in my food had. I found that increasing my carbs much beyond 60-70g per day or eating more than one small portion of wheat per day bring on tiredness, despondency, and that tight feeling in my feet that indicates the start of fluid retention. More than one or two glasses of wine, or drinking wine if I'm already tired or stressed will do it too. My weight seemed more affected by calories than carbs, though if I eat more carbs I'm generally eating more calories as well, so they're not entirely independent. I was also able to match the amount of food, the way my weight was going, and the level of hunger I experienced. Amazingly enough, if I feel hungry a lot of the time my weight goes down; if I never get hungry at all, it goes up; if I'm getting hungry as meal time approaches, I stay the same.

I liked having all those numbers in my spreadsheet, but I stopped journalling because I wanted to feel as if my eating was more natural, and less obsessively controlled, but I'm glad that I established the baseline, and I'll do it again any time either my weight or health indicates a need to review what I'm eating. I've actually noticed that just the act of recording what I eat makes my trim my portions slightly :rolleyes: , so I generally start to lose a bit of weight just by starting the journalling!

Do you record your food? Carbs? Protein? Calories? Do you do it all the time, spot check (like monitor Mondays)? For a while when you need to get back on track?

Shadow
08-07-2006, 08:46 AM
Well, I journalled faithfully for 3 or 3 1/2 years - or maybe it was closer to 4 years :rolleyes:. But eventually I got fed up with it and felt like my spreadsheet was controlling my life :lol:. I panicked when I thought of giving up the accountability, but thanks to Mitra's encouragement ;), I went for a trial run of not journalling and haven't gone back to it. I do, of course, keep a running tally in my head of where I'm at for each meal but no longer obsess about keeping it all written down. I do, however, think that it was very advantageous to have journalled for so long - and should I really need to correct my eating again, I will definitely return to it. If I were more adventuresome in my eating, I would probably still journal - but since I tend to eat the same meals over and over, it just seems a bit silly to write them down every day :p.

Carmen Sandiego
08-07-2006, 09:03 AM
I think I might do the spot-check thing?? I used to be really aware of it too but I tend to go through spells where I eat relatively the same thing for about a week and logging that seemed redundant! :eek:

When I introduce something new I also tend to chart it, just to see what kind of reaction (if any) I have.

deirdra
08-12-2006, 02:42 PM
I'm still journaling, but since I use DietPower software with all my favourite foods available with one click, this takes minimal effort. The main reason is because I've been using it to aid in detecting the foods I am allergic or intolerant to. Things like 1T of wheat cause me to retain 1 lb that will come off over a day or two (sometimes it feels like it is all in my sinuses), but a couple of cups of dairy cause me to hold on to 3-5 extra lbs for a week or more. Scary. Not that I'm worried about water weight, but that these "wholesome" foods are causing such drammatic inflammation.

banshee
08-14-2006, 09:36 AM
I don't journal my food now, but I journal other things. I found that, for me, journaling food makes it feel too much like I'm "dieting". I did journal at first, but after 5 years on plan, I pretty much know what I can and can't eat. I do still journal my exercise so that I can keep track of my progress there, and I journal my daily weight/bodyfat so I can see the trends over time. I also journal my measurements (when I remember to take them :rolleyes:). I try for once a month, but sometimes it's less often than that.

miralin
08-14-2006, 09:27 PM
I do sort of a spot check thing on fitday. I don't do it every day, but I'm trying to remember to hit it a couple times a week.

Having already eliminated some of the stuff I KNOW I can't tolerate helps - since I just don't eat them, there's no worry about portions, etc. But if I ever get to the point where I want to try say eating eggs again or something, then I will likely journal more.

Mitra
08-15-2006, 01:16 AM
I don't journal my food now, but I journal other things. I found that, for me, journaling food makes it feel too much like I'm "dieting". I did journal at first, but after 5 years on plan, I pretty much know what I can and can't eat.

That was what I found. It wasn't that I minded making the record, but that I felt it made food something to be measured and controlled more than something to be tasted and savoured. It seemed to make me focus more on the quantity than the quality of my food. I did like having the record of what I'd eaten, but I know I always have the option of picking it up again if I need to.